How many times have you wept while looking for street signs that
weren't there? How often have you driven for blocks trying to
identify the street you were on, while the signs named only the side
streets? Couriers and taxi drivers will tell you those missing signs
are their biggest gripe, with missing or elusive house numbers a
close second. And for emergency vehicles, signs and numbers can mean
the difference between life and death.
Other first-world countries - indeed, other Australian cities -
name both streets at intersections. Why doesn't Sydney? One problem
is that the relevant Australian Standard says it isn't necessary.
The standard needs changing. It's also because street signs are the
responsibility of local councils, and Sydney has 40 of them, each
doing its own thing. Willoughby, Rockdale and Sydney City do name
both streets at all intersections, and Hurstville and Fairfield have
now begun. In those council areas, a street directory will rescue a
lost driver at the nearest corner.
Some councils will argue the cost of additional signs is
prohibitive. Yet the very same councils replace perfectly
serviceable signs with new ones bearing the municipal logo while
leaving major streets unnamed at most intersections. It doesn't
matter that both signs on a post don't match; what matters is that
they are both there.
Additional signs are within the means of any council; the cost of
kerbing and guttering a street of 25 homes would pay for 2,000 to
3,000 street name blades. And the work can be spread over several
years.
But we not only need more signs - we need more informative signs.
Some councils spend big on deluxe signs that project a glossy
corporate image, yet are not so successful at helping people find
their way. Some have adopted deeper 200mm blades only to use the
extra space for their name or, worse, their slogans, instead of the
suburb's name and property numbers.
Hornsby Shire Council addressed all these problems in its recent
"Navigator's Paradise" trial in the Dence Park area of Epping. The
trial followed requests from the local Neighbourhood Watch group
which wanted to persuade Sydney's councils to install the missing
signs and kerb numbers for every home. The project grew to include
the content of signs.
The council supplied materials for kerb numbering and 16 new
signs bearing the council logo, the street name, the suburb name,
and property numbers.
The fire and ambulance services had asked for numbers on the
signs because they indicate whether to turn right or left at
intersections.
Numbers must be shown for both sides of the street, but
displaying, say, 12-20 and 9-15 presents too much information for a
driver to take in and act on quickly and safely.
So the signs used in the trial employed so-called "wedge"
notation, which shows only the first numbers, on both sides of the
named street. Parentheses designate the number on the side of the
road opposite the sign, and a wedge, or incline, symbol shows the
direction the numbers run, increasing toward the thick end and
decreasing toward the thin end. So 12-20 and 9-15 becomes 12 (9) and
a wedge sloping up.
Turning into a cross street, a driver would turn right for a
number higher than 12 or 9 and left for a lower number. The
economical presentation allows a quick, confident decision. Drivers
travelling straight ahead can tell at each corner where they are on
a street and will know at once if they have overshot their
destination.
The trial of the wedge system was requested by senior officials
from local units of the ambulance, fire brigade and police.
The system was explained through newspaper articles, public
meetings, letterbox drops and signs at entry points to the test
area.
The trial ran from August 1998 to June 1999 and the public
feedback I gathered showed that people wanted:
Both streets named at intersections;
The suburb named on street signs in metropolitan areas;
Property numbers on all signs, not just those in CBDs or on
arterial roads;
Kerb numbers.
The wedge notation was well accepted once it had been explained
and the wedge symbol was liked for its ability to convey direction
instantaneously.
Feedback also revealed that many road users do not notice or
understand the arrowheads and endcuts some councils use to indicate
if a street name applies on both sides of an intersection. Sometimes
the location of blades suits pedestrians but not drivers. Councils
within one metropolitan area should strive for uniform formats, and
street name blades should be larger.
The heads of emergency services thought wedge notation and other
features of "Navigator's Paradise" were a success. Their view was
endorsed by State Opposition spokesman on police, Andrew Tink; the
then mayor of Hornsby Shire (now its deputy), Steven Pringle; the
Epping Civic Trust; and three outlying Neighbourhood Watch
groups.
In February, Hornsby deferred a decision on signs while it
explored interest in wedge notation among its six fellow councils in
the Northern Sydney Regional Organisation of Councils (NSROC). It
awaits a report.
The public liked the trial signs, but many thought they were too
busy and the numbers too small.
So retired design engineer Len Alexander, of Epping, submitted a
leaner design, moving the numbers to the end of the sign and making
them as large as the street name. He called the result a
"Lifesaver", and it has been endorsed by local emergency service
officials.
At the end of the trial, Hornsby Shire engineers sent a
questionnaire to 820 residents of the test area. Of the 285
residents who responded, 52 per cent picked the wedge notation as
the best of three methods of numbering. Thirty per cent nominated
the Australian Standard.
Educating the public about the wedge need involve no more than a
little space in a council's regular column in local papers. As with
T2 and T3 in transit lanes, use would generate awareness.
In the words of Nike, "Just do it".
Hornsby Shire could make a decision about its signs as early as
Wednesday at its monthly meeting. If it begins filling the gaps at
its street corners with Lifesaver signs, and its kerbs with house
numbers, and if all other councils follow the example, Sydney will
indeed become a navigator's paradise.
Beatrice Player is the area co-ordinator of Neighbourhood
Watch area Eastwood 3, covering the Dence Park area of Epping. She
is instigator of the Hornsby Shire Council's trial of navigational
aids in that area, detailed at www.tovegin.com.au/community/streetsigns.htm
For more information on wedge notation, send a stamped,
self-addressed business-size envelope to Street Signs, P.O. Box 134,
Epping 1710.
(Since publication, above contact details have changed. See
Contact Us.)

Page created 17 July, 2002. Last updated
19 August, 2003 04:39:31 +1000